Home > Security & Protection > Which water-resistant is better?

Which water-resistant is better?

Author: Hou

Mar. 07, 2024

167 0

Tags: Security & Protection

Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed's editors. Purchases made through the links below may earn us and our publishing partners a commission.

If you're shopping for new headphones, a new Bluetooth speaker, or even a new phone you're probably wondering how well they can handle water. Maybe you need headphones for running or just the occasional rough commute, or perhaps you'll be jamming to your tunes in heavy weather or near a pool. If so, you've probably come across dozens of products claiming to be protected against sweat, water, splashes, and everything in between.

Whether a product is labeled as sweat-resistant, sweatproof, water-resistant, or waterproof, if you want to know what it can handle, you'll want to look for its "IP" rating. Denoted with two numbers or one number and an "x" such as "IPX7," an IP rating can tell you how much water and dust exposure a product is certified to withstand. Below, we'll break down these terms so you can be confident about the protection of your next purchase.

Waterproof vs water-resistant

Credit: Reviewed/Ryan Waniata

The Sonos Roam is rated for IP67 dust and water resistance. As detailed below, it is fully protected against dust and dunkable in fresh water.

What's the difference between "waterproof" and "water-resistant"? To find the answer, you need to know how the IP rating—AKA Ingress Protection rating—actually works.

IP ratings are a (mostly) standardized way to describe how well a gadget can keep out dust and water.

IP ratings are a (mostly) standardized way to describe how well any gadget is at keeping out solids (like dust) and liquids (like water). Any IP rating you see has two characters—for example, "IP67". The first number—6—tells you how good it is at keeping out dust, while the second—7—tells you how well it keeps out water. Higher numbers typically mean it's better at that task.

For example, if you see a pair of headphones with a rating of IP55, the first five indicates that headphones are "dust protected"—they allow some dust in, but not enough to interfere with the normal operation.

The second number indicates how well the headphones keep out water. IP55 headphones can be sprayed with a stream of water for 5-10 minutes (depending on the test setup) without being damaged. Just remember the two numbers are independent, so if you have three headphones rated IPX5, IP55, and IP65, they're all equally good at keeping water out.

While plenty of durable, sports-ready electronics currently on the market have a dust rating of at least 5 or 6, many electronics aren't tested for resistance against dust. For instance, plenty of portable speakers or wireless headphones will offer an IPX7 or IPX4 resistance rating respectively. This means you'll want to keep either of these products away from dust or ingress.

What does an IP rating actually mean?

Credit: Reviewed.com/Jackson Ruckar

The Jabra Elite Active 75t earbuds offer IP57 protection, offering good dust protection and fully submergible water protection so you can rinse them off.

Most products you'll find with dust resistance usually end up with a 5 (meaning ingress of dust is prevented sufficiently so as not to interfere with satisfactory operation) or 6 (meaning dust ingress is entirely prevented). As such, we'll mostly be focusing on the water resistance rating. We'll start with a "2" water resistance rating below, as this is really the minimum of any sort of notable protection.

  • IPX2: Water drips at a 15-degree angle or less have no harmful effect.
  • IPX3: Water sprays at any angle up to 60 degrees from the vertical have no harmful effect.
  • IPX4: Water splashes over 5-10 minutes have no harmful effect.
  • IPX5: Water projected from a small nozzle for 5 minutes has no harmful effect.
  • IPX6: Water projected in a powerful jet for 1 minute has no harmful effect.
  • IPX7: Can survive submersion in 1 meter of water for 30 minutes.
  • IPX8: Can survive submersion in >1 meter for >30 minutes; terms agreed to by the manufacturer.

So if you want properly waterproof electronics, we highly recommend a rating of at least IPX7. If you're simply looking for basic water protection for things like a few splashes, sweat or rain, anything at IPX4 or better is well protected.

To put it further in context, an IPX7 rating is something you can expect from most modern smartphones, the majority of sports-oriented headphones, as well as the vast majority of new portable Bluetooth speakers. An IPX4 rating is common for complex electronics also designed for mobility, such as noise-canceling headphones and earbuds (though some go well above this rating.)

It's also important to note that all of these ratings are for fresh water only. If you live near the coast, you probably already know that any brush with salt water can quickly spell trouble for your electronics, no matter the IP. The same goes for soda, coffee, etc.

See also:
Security & Protection
10 Tips for Choosing Protective Clothing: Safeguarding Yourself in Style
How to check the pressure and safety of a CNG cylinder?
What is the best paint for parking lot?
What is the highest index available?
What type of glass is best for buildings?
What is building glass called?

Credit: Reviewed.com / Jackson Ruckar

We tested an older pair of MPOW headphones to prove out their IP rating.

One annoying quirk of the rating system? Being rated for submersion doesn't technically mean that it is also certified to withstand water jets. If it can withstand both submersion and water jets, the headphones should have two ratings listed. Most companies just list the higher rating—likely because this is so confusing—so it's often unclear exactly what a buyer should expect.

If you see a non-standard rating like "IPX-68" it either doesn't meet the standard or wasn't independently tested.

This is especially true because some lesser-known manufacturers write things like IPX-68, which is non-standard. It is very likely not conforming to the actual IP standard or the company didn't verify those claims independently. If you see a non-standard IP rating with a dash, extra letter, or anything else, you shouldn't trust the rating.

On the other hand, if a rating looks good but one of the dust/water numbers has been replaced with an X—such as our IPX7 examples above—it simply means it has been tested for one and not the other. Most of the time the one missing will be the dust/ingress protection. This is probably because water is the more likely candidate for electronics failures.

With all this in mind, we recommend you apply this knowledge the next time you buy electronics like wireless earbuds, a portable speaker, phone, or anything else you want to be protected against the elements.

Even if you find that better waterproofing is more expensive, it could pay for itself over time by allowing you to avoid replacing cheaper products that may be more easily damaged when it comes to exposure to the elements.

Prices were accurate at the time this article was published but may change over time.

The product experts at Reviewed have all your shopping needs covered. Follow Reviewed on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, TikTok, or Flipboard for the latest deals, product reviews, and more.

Learn about IP68 and 5ATM waterproof rating.

Follow Blackview. Welcome to Blackview blog. Blackview, the global's well-known rugged phone brand.


What's the difference between IP68 and 5ATM waterproof rating? And who is better? Today, let's learn about it. IP68 and 5ATM are both standards used to measure the water resistance of electronic devices, particularly smartphones and smartwatches. However, they differ in their approach to measuring water resistance.



IP68


IP68 is a standard set by the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) that measures the degree of protection provided by an enclosure against the ingress of solid objects, dust, and water. The first digit (6) indicates the level of protection against dust and the second digit (8) indicates the level of protection against water. The bigger the digit is, the stronger proof grade is. A device with an IP68 rating is considered dust-tight and can withstand immersion in water up to 1.5 meters deep for up to 30 minutes. Therefore, the rugged IP68 phones gained deep favor from outdoor lovers.



5ATM


5ATM, on the other hand, is a standard used by watch manufacturers to indicate the level of water resistance of their watches. Note, it's dedicated to watches, not for phones and more. 5ATM stands for "5 atmospheres" or "5 bar," which means that a watch with a 5ATM rating can withstand pressure equivalent to being submerged in water up to 50 meters deep. However, it does not necessarily mean that the watch can be used for diving or swimming at such depths. It also depends on other factors such as watch structure design, sealed design and more.



The IP68 waterproof rating can be used into the smartphone, rugged tablet, and smartwatch and more, but 5ATM waterproof rating is just used in a watch. You can say you want to buy a 5ATM smartwatch, but you can't say you want to buy a 5ATM waterproof phone. In terms of which one is better, it depends on your needs and usage.

If you plan to use your electronic device primarily for everyday activities like showering or washing dishes, an IP68 rating should suffice. However, if you plan to use your device for swimming or water sports, a 5ATM rating may be more appropriate. If you are looking for a budget diving smartwatch, the Blackview R1 is worth hands on.



Read also,

Which water-resistant is better?

IP68 vs 5ATM waterproof rating, which Is Better?

Suggested reading:
Rust-Oleum Professional 1 gal. Flat Yellow Exterior Traffic Striping Paint 2548402
How to Save Money When Buying glass for sale

Comments

0